Craig,
I'm curious to know about the construction of the RG-6 cable that you used
for
your test?
Was this just braid shielded? And if so what was the shield coverage? Was
there any foil over the dielectric, and if so was that foil bonded to the
dielectric or just folded?
Good quality RG-6 cable will have a polyfoam dielectric. Over that will be
a
foil covering. This foil will be bonded (glued) to the dielectric and
overlapped along the seam. You can tell this because you can't peel it
back if
you strip away the outer jacket and braided shield. If it's loose or the
seam
opens, it's pure junk. Then over the top of the foil should be a shield of
98%
coverage. This will be easy to see by eye. If you can see through the
braid to
the foil or the dielectric if there is no foil, i.e. the weaves of the
braid
are open. It's junk. After that, if it's overhead RG-6 there will be a
black
vinyl jacket and generally a single messenger wire. This is designed to
support the weight of the cable as it hangs in the air. This is generally
called "figure-8" cable, because of the way a cut cross-section looks. If
it's
designed for underground use, there will be no messenger, but there will
be a
sticky flooding compound between the braid and the jacket. This is
designed to
keep out water should the jacket get nicked. The jacket of direct burial
cable
is generally thicker too.
You'd be surprised at how much junk CATV cable there is out there. I
always
strip back the end of anything I'm going to buy if I don't already know
the
source and examine it visually.
Additionally, I always place a ferrite choke over the outside of the cable
at
the termination end as well as the receiver end, to choke off any
common-mode
currents on the outside of the shield.
As to quad-shield cable, the additional shielding effects of this may be
offset
by the fact that's most of it is not designed for outdoor use. Connectors
are
more difficult to install, though not by much of you have the proper tools
and
connectors.
As to connectors, what did you use on that RG-6 cable you tested with? Was
this a standard 1/4 inch cable prep (stripped with a calibrated stripper
tool)
and the foil left intact to fit inside of the connector barrel, then the
shield
fanned out symmetrically and crimped using the approved crimping tool for
the
connector used? This varies according to the connector manufacturer.
The problem with any balanced feedline is always line-balance. Since the
electric and magnetic field of the signals extends outside the physical
area of
the twisted pair, there will always be interaction between pairs within a
CAT
type cable. You would need far more spacing between pairs than is
available in
the CAT cable design to prevent interaction between pairs. Additionally,
laying the cable on the ground or near to conductive surfaces will also
upset
the line-balance (for UTP cable.) And this prevents the common-mode
rejection
of signals common to both wires of the twisted pair from canceling
completely.
Shielded CAT cable is a different animal, outside effects being much less,
but
the inter-pair coupling is still an issue.
Anyway... I'm just curious about the test setup.
TIA
Rick Kunath
_______________________________________________
IRCA mailing list
IRCA@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/irca
Opinions expressed in messages on this mailing list are those of the
original contributors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the
IRCA, its editors, publishing staff, or officers
For more information: http://www.ircaonline.org
To Post a message: irca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx