[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [IRCA] WC Nov 5 snapshot - SDR shoot-out

Ok...Love my ELAD. Live in a very RF rich area (just south of Boston MA). Had a Drake R8A and loved it. Got the Perseus and it beat the R8A by a decent margin imho. Then I bought the ELAD mainly for its wide band FM capture capability. Found that in most cases it's the equal to or better than the Perseus especially in audio quality which I find to be much softer on these aging ears than the Perseus. The one area I'd give the Perseus a big plus on was NDB dxng.
Also if you are only dxng MW (or NDB's and SW) and not FM then a middle of the road laptop will suffice. I purchased a refurb Lenovo quad core a few years back for about $350 and it worked fine for everything and wasn't too bad at handling the load for FM captures. Also the ELAD is $519.00 USD ($695 Canadian) and not $1000. A lot less than the Perseus. The great part about the ELAD if you are an FM dxer is that no external downcoverter is needed (like you need for the Perseus) so no additional cost. 

Keith McGinnis
Hingham MA
ELAD SDR with 50x100 switched termination superloop running NE/SW and a Wellbrook 1530LNP Imperium along with a DX Engineering NCC1 Phaser for LW, MW and SW. 2 Innov 11 element antennas with Bolin Phase Box for FM 

On 11/5/2016 9:19 PM, R. Colin Newell wrote:

There is a noticeable difference with audio quality between Laptops and work stations.

Consider this: $1000 Elad + $1000 laptop gives you a decent set up...
But a 2nd hand Drake at $700 mops the floor with the Elad. Do the math.
I know SDR's are the future but the Elad or Perseus are paper weights without a solid PC desktop or laptop.

If you run the Elad with the ATT off, there is "ADC" clipping, whatever that is -- and I'm in a low signal area. The only choice is clicking ATT ON. But no mention anywhere I could find what the attenuation is.

No passband tuning with the Elad and without a high quality wheel mouse or gaming mouse, actually operating the Elad is a two handed operation.

Still going to keep the comparison going. Gotta know.

Colin Newell - CoffeeCrew.com - VA7WWV - Victoria - BC


On Nov 5, 2016, at 4:13 PM, Walter Salmaniw <canswl@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I can't comment on the Elad, but the Perseus is superb.  Every bit as good
as any of the best classic receivers mentioned.  There is a real learning
curve, though, to use them optimally.  Audio is perfect, but very much
dependent on your sound card.  My high end Dell produces wonderful audio.
I have been told that the Elad should be as good as the Perseus.  Wonder
what the issue is.  Doesn't sound right to me.   Walt (At the Glistening
Waters, PEI DXpedition, and listening to almost armchair copy of Nigeria on
917 kHz).

On Sat, Nov 5, 2016 at 9:13 PM, R. Colin Newell <coffeecanuck@xxxxxxxxx>
wrote:


SDR's are like digital cameras...
The closer you look, the less they look like film.

Great for spectrum analysis and for portable operation when you are
traveling.

Hard to beat the warmth of a well designed receiver.

Colin Newell - CoffeeCrew.com - VA7WWV - Victoria - BC


On Nov 5, 2016, at 12:21 PM, Richard N Allen <richarda@xxxxxxxxxxxx>

wrote:

Colin:

Thanks for the review.

I tried a Drake R8 many years ago when it was first released.  It's an

outstanding receiver.


I've been pondering a new SDR but think I'll stick with my old

WR-G313e.  I'm sitting here now at mid-day hearing "Jack Rabbit" football
from WNAX-570, Yankton SD (S7 @ 726 km/451 mi), on the WiNRADiO hooked to a
long wire.  It's an easy to use receiver and still works on Windows 10.  It
simply need a better aerial and I have an ALA1503LNP-NA on order.


I also have a R75 which is going back to ICOM soon for repairs.   It

just quit and I don't know why.


Good DX.

Richard.

Sent from my iPad
--
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.

_______________________________________________
IRCA mailing list
IRCA@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/irca

Opinions expressed in messages on this mailing list are those of the

original contributors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the
IRCA, its editors, publishing staff, or officers


For more information: http://www.ircaonline.org

To Post a message: irca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

_______________________________________________
IRCA mailing list
IRCA@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/irca

Opinions expressed in messages on this mailing list are those of the
original contributors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the
IRCA, its editors, publishing staff, or officers

For more information: http://www.ircaonline.org

To Post a message: irca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

_______________________________________________
IRCA mailing list
IRCA@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/irca

Opinions expressed in messages on this mailing list are those of the original contributors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the IRCA, its editors, publishing staff, or officers

For more information: http://www.ircaonline.org

To Post a message: irca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx


_______________________________________________
IRCA mailing list
IRCA@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/irca

Opinions expressed in messages on this mailing list are those of the original contributors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the IRCA, its editors, publishing staff, or officers

For more information: http://www.ircaonline.org

To Post a message: irca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx



_______________________________________________
IRCA mailing list
IRCA@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/irca

Opinions expressed in messages on this mailing list are those of the original contributors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the IRCA, its editors, publishing staff, or officers

For more information: http://www.ircaonline.org

To Post a message: irca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx