Re: [Swlfest] OT?: Digital radio HD-One last point
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Swlfest] OT?: Digital radio HD-One last point



In a message dated 1/8/2006 1:03:01 PM Eastern Standard Time, kb3jam@xxxxxxxxxxx writes:
Just my opinion but the issue with broadcast radio AM/FM is not the signal
method its what they have for content.  WHYY (NPR) has good content and I
listen to them.  Sirius for example has so much more choice (not being part
of the clear channel effect).  Also as Mark has pointed out IBOC is not the
same quality as Sirius or XM.

Just my two cents.

Sid


On 1/8/06 12:34 PM, "Mark Phillips" <g7ltt@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Erm,  the digital transmission of which you speak are not near XM and
> Sirius. HD radio is otherwise known as IBOC (as those that attended my
> forum last year will know)
>
> IBOC/HD radio is a simultaneous broadcast on the same carrier as the
> regular station. In other words, if the radio stations analogue output
> is 97.5MHz FM then the HD output is there also.  There is no spearate HD
> band.
>
> Would this be the right time to start trashing IBOC (It Buggers Other
> Channels)?
>
> For those that are interested, XM and Sirius transmit about 50 watts in
> the 2.2-2.4GHz range.
>
> Mark, G7LTT/KC2ENI
> Randolph, NJ
> http://www.g7ltt.com
>
>
> WagnerND@xxxxxxx wrote:
>> In a message dated 1/8/2006 2:16:23 AM Eastern Standard Time,
>> SaulBro@xxxxxxx writes:
>>
>>     Hi everyone,
>>
>>     Last week I attended the launch of WHYY-FM's digital HD channel here
>>     in Philadelphia.  CEO Bill Marrazzo and "Fresh Air" host Terry Gross
>>     pressed the big button to inaugurate the service.  I had the
>>     opportunity to publicly question the chief engineer about possible
>>     IBOQ interference to weaker adjacent channels.  The food was great!
>>     But that ain't all...
>>
>>     I won the "door prize", a Boston Acoustics Recepter Radio HD!  (I
>>     should only be so lucky with the raffles at SWL Fest)    What a nice
>>     little unit...great sound even without tone control, and I haven't
>>     even bothered to set up the second speaker for stereo.   WHYY's HD
>>     channel does drop out on occasion, but all in all pretty good
>>     reception if I set the unit in a good place and extend the wire
>>     antenna.  I'd be interested in hearing of others' experiences with
>>     similar units.
>>
>>     I was shocked, after an internet search, to find that the radio
>>     sells for no less than $499!    It would be lovely to keep it, but I
>>     am thinking seriously of selling it.  It does give me several hours
>>     of BBC World Service in the morning, the ability to catch various
>>     programs at times other than their broadcast on the regular FM
>>     channel, and lots of classical music on WHYY;  I've listened to a
>>     few other HD channels from other stations, but I'm not sure my
>>     listening interests justify keeping it.  So if any of you might be
>>     interested, please let me know...I could, of course, bring it to the
>>     SWL Fest for examination or purchase.   Full details at
>>     <http://www.bostonacoustics.com/home_product.aspx?product_id=325>.
>>
>>     Cheers,
>>
>>     Saul Broudy
>>     Philadelphia, PA
>>     215-567-0193
>>     Cell:  215-356-2136
>>
>>     _______________________________________________
>>     Swlfest mailing list
>>     Swlfest@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>>     http://arizona.hard-core-dx.com/mailman/listinfo/swlfest
>> >>
>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>> -Sid, The reason I mentioned XM Satellite radio in my Email to you was because of a new antenna that is coming out. It may be out now, I'll check Terk & a few others I know. But, in one of the Radio Broadcasters Enewsletters I subscribe to they had an article about a new XM Sirius Antenna that will bring XM/Sirius radio to most receivers that already have RDS, or some kind of Data Sevice capabilities built in. Like the new Eton E 1, it has no built in XM radio guts, it's all in the antenna.
I have a trial antenna now and I am going to try it out on a few multi band portables I own that have RDS but are analog & no XM. If you have ever seen the Terk, or other model antennas for radios like the Eton E 1, all of the receive circuits are in the antenna, not in the radio. One person properly pointed out that XM/Sirius signals are in the 2,2 to 2.4 GHz Bands, which is true. But, it is the antenna for radios like the E 1 that receives the signals & processes them for reception on non satellite receivers. Many of these receivers are referred to as "XM Ready". That means they have an antenna input for whichever Satellite receiver they pick out.
 
73 John Wagner, Pickerington, Ohio
_______________________________________________
Swlfest mailing list
Swlfest@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://arizona.hard-core-dx.com/mailman/listinfo/swlfest